← All insights

How to Find a Marketing Agency for Your MSP (and Avoid the Wrong One)

You’ve decided to stop doing marketing on Friday afternoons between tickets. Maybe referrals have slowed, maybe you want to grow faster than your network can introduce you, or maybe you tried a marketing hire who didn’t understand what an MSP sells. Now you need an agency, and the first search shows you dozens of them, most promising more leads.

Picking the wrong one is expensive. Not just the retainer, but the months you lose before you realize it isn’t working, and the website or ad account you might not own when you leave. This guide is a checklist for finding a marketing agency for your MSP and telling the good ones from the rest.

A note before we start: we’re a B2B marketing agency, and we work with MSPs. We’ve written this to be useful whether or not you ever talk to us, and we tell you how we answer these questions at the end.

Before you look: decide what you’re hiring for

Most bad agency relationships start with a vague brief. “We need more leads” lets any agency say yes. Answer these five questions first:

  1. What is the goal in revenue? For example, $15,000 in new monthly recurring revenue within 12 months. Divide by your average client value to see how many new clients that means.
  2. Which channel do you need help with? SEO and your website, outbound outreach, paid ads, content and email, events, or all of it. An agency that’s excellent at one is often average at the others.
  3. What will you keep in house? Most MSPs keep sales calls, assessments, and proposals. Be clear about where the agency’s job ends and yours begins.
  4. What can you spend, and for how long? Search takes months. If you can only commit to 90 days, choose channels that produce conversations faster.
  5. Who on your team owns it? An agency needs someone to approve content, answer questions, and follow up on leads quickly. If nobody has time, fix that first.

Our IT marketing guide shows how to work back from a revenue goal to the number of opportunities you need, which makes every agency conversation sharper.

Specialist or generalist?

There are two broad kinds of agency you’ll meet.

MSP-specialist agencies work only or mostly with MSPs. They know the vocabulary, the buyers, and the vendor ecosystem, so they ramp up quickly. The trade-off: many sell packaged websites, content, and newsletters to many MSPs. If a competitor across town uses the same agency, your content may look very similar to theirs.

B2B generalists with IT services experience work across industries but have done meaningful work for IT companies. They may bring sharper positioning and ideas from outside the MSP world. The trade-off: they need more time to learn your business, and some never really do.

Neither is automatically better. What matters is evidence that they understand how IT buyers choose a provider, and that they won’t sell the same thing to the company down the street. Ask both kinds about exclusivity in your market.

Where to find candidates

Build a shortlist of three to five from more than one source:

  • Other MSP owners. Ask in your peer group, at user group meetings, or in MSP communities online. Ask what results they got, not just whether they liked the agency.
  • Your vendors and distributors. Many run partner programs with marketing resources or lists of agencies they work with. Ask your partner manager.
  • Review and directory sites. Sites such as Clutch list agencies by industry and include client reviews. Treat directory rankings with care, since some placements are paid.
  • Search. Search for the services you want plus “MSP.” An agency that ranks well for its own MSP terms has at least shown it can do SEO for itself.
  • Podcasts and events. People who teach useful things to MSP owners in public are easier to evaluate than those who only pitch.

10 questions to ask every agency

Ask each candidate the same questions so you can compare answers.

  1. Which MSPs or IT services companies have you worked with, and what changed for them? Good answer: named examples with specific results, and honesty if they haven’t worked with an MSP like yours.
  2. How will you measure success? Good answer: qualified opportunities, signed agreements, and new monthly recurring revenue, not just traffic, rankings, and followers.
  3. What happens in the first 90 days? Good answer: a concrete plan with checkpoints. Weak answer: “We’ll start with a discovery phase” and nothing more specific.
  4. Who will do the work? Good answer: names and roles. Ask whether any of it is outsourced or resold from another provider.
  5. What do you need from us? Good answer: a realistic estimate of your time for interviews, approvals, and sales feedback. Be wary of “nothing, we handle it all.”
  6. Do you work with other MSPs in my area? Good answer: a straight yes or no, and an offer of exclusivity if it matters to you.
  7. Who owns the website, content, ad accounts, and data? Good answer: you do, in your own accounts, with the agency given access.
  8. How do you define a lead? Especially for pay-per-lead or appointment-setting deals. A lead that doesn’t match your ideal client is a cost, not a result.
  9. What does reporting look like? Ask to see a sample report. It should connect activity to pipeline, not just list what was published.
  10. How do we part ways if it isn’t working? Good answer: a clear notice period and a handover of everything you own.

Ask for two references, and call them. Ask the references what the agency is weak at. Every agency has a weak spot, and the reference who can name it is giving you an honest picture.

Red flags

Walk away, or at least slow down, if you hear any of these:

  • Guaranteed rankings or a guaranteed number of leads. Nobody controls Google, and nobody can guarantee your close rate. Google itself warns against SEOs who guarantee rankings. Google: Do you need an SEO?
  • Long contracts with no exit. A 12-month commitment with no way out protects the agency, not you.
  • The agency owns your assets. Your website on their platform, ads in their account, or your contact list in their system all make leaving painful.
  • Reporting that stops at clicks. If they can’t tell you which work produced conversations, you’ll never know if it’s working.
  • No access to your own accounts. You should be able to log into your analytics, Search Console, ad accounts, and CRM at any time.
  • The same website as your competitor. Ask to see live client sites. If they all look alike, yours will too.

How MSP marketing agencies charge

You’ll usually see one of four pricing models:

ModelHow it worksGood forWatch out for
Monthly retainerA fixed fee for ongoing workSEO, content, ongoing campaignsVague deliverables; ask what you get each month
Project feeA fixed price for a defined buildWebsites, positioning, a campaign launchScope creep and who maintains it afterwards
Pay per lead or appointmentA price for each lead or booked meetingTesting outbound quicklyLoose lead definitions and poor-fit meetings
HybridA smaller retainer plus a performance elementSharing risk on a clear goalDisagreements about what counts as performance

Whatever the model, compare proposals by what you’ll get and how it will be measured, not just the monthly number.

Contract terms to insist on

Before you sign, make sure the agreement covers:

  • Ownership. You own the website, content, designs, ad accounts, and data.
  • Access. You have admin access to every account, from day one.
  • Deliverables. What will be delivered each month or at each milestone.
  • Reporting. How often you’ll get reports and what they’ll include.
  • Notice and exit. How much notice either side must give, and what the handover includes.
  • Exclusivity. Whether the agency can work with direct competitors in your market.

Score your shortlist

Score each agency from 1 to 5 on the same criteria, multiply by the weight, and compare totals. Adjust the weights to match what matters most to you.

CriterionWeight
Relevant experience with IT services companies3
Measures success by pipeline and revenue3
Clear 90-day plan with checkpoints2
You own all assets and accounts2
References you spoke to were positive and specific2
Fair contract and exit terms1
Exclusivity in your market1

What the first 90 days should look like

A good agency won’t promise revenue in month one, but you should see progress you can check:

  • Days 1 to 30: positioning and goals agreed, tracking set up so every lead carries a source, account access confirmed, and a prioritized plan.
  • Days 31 to 60: the first work live, such as rewritten service pages, an assessment offer, or the first outreach campaign.
  • Days 61 to 90: the first results report connecting activity to conversations, and a clear decision about what to do more of.

If you reach day 90 with nothing live and no tracking in place, that tells you most of what you need to know.

How we answer these questions

Since we’re asking you to put agencies through this, here’s where we stand on the facts. We’re a B2B marketing agency for companies with complex sales, and managed IT and IT services are the industries our SEO work focuses on. Our published case studies are with technical services firms, a healthcare AI consultancy and an FPGA engineering consultancy, not MSPs, and we’ll tell you that on the first call. We measure our work by qualified opportunities and signed agreements, and we set up tracking before we spend your money on anything else.

If you’d like to put us through the checklist, see how we work with IT services companies and MSPs or our MSP SEO services. And if you want to understand the work before you hire anyone, start with our MSP SEO guide.

Ready to build the system?

Your expertise is the product.
Your go-to-market is the multiplier.

If this resonated, let's talk about what B2B marketing built around your buyers could look like for your company.

Get in touch →